I find this morally reprehensible. I have always spoken against defederazation when others have mentioned it. This is too much. Apologies if this upsets anyone.
Palestinians are human beings and have a right to life.
Edit: I have been persuaded by some thoughtful replies. I will block them from my view. I no longer support making the decision for others. Thanks all.
If your comment contains the following, it will be removed from this community:
- Calling for the dissolution of Israel, or calling for a one-state solution without specifying equal rights for all people; Jewish in particular.
- Calling for a destruction, annihilation, an end of all Zionism or the like.
- Equating Israeli actions and (historical) Nazism.
- The slogan “from the river…”
- Endorsement of or justifications for Hamas or Hezbollah, or slogans or graphics positively referring to these organizations. These are considered terrorist organizations in Germany.
- … and obviously: Any of the common antisemitic tropes or calls to violence against Jews or Israelis
Comments will not be removed for the following:
- Denouncing genocide.
- Denouncing Israeli war crimes.
- Criticizing Zionism as an ideology or political movement.
- Referring to the current Israeli government as “criminal,” “expansionist,” or “far-right”.
pretty reasonable, admins can’t change the law.
they cannot change the law, but also they don’t have to follow the law because they aren’t within that country’s jurisdiction.
From what I’ve heard these are german laws and their instance is based in austria. Those are different countries.
The slogan “from the river…”
Literally not a terrorist statement, sorry it just isn’t and even including this makes it obvious how poorly thought through or examined Zionist’s beliefs are. It should scare us all and I do not say that lightly.
If you will not resist your country deciding a statement is a terrorist belief when it provide zero actual evidence…the war is already lost and we are in for a hellish future.
The feddit admins are the worst flavor of morally bankrupt, which is cowardly AND morally bankrupt.
Removed by mod
My post doesn’t seem to violate these rules, even if I find them overly-restrictive. Glad to see that it wasn’t removed.
I just copied what exactly they are going to remove.
Tbh if German laws are so strict it might be better to just disallow any kind of political content on feddit instance and just stick with hobby/meme type of content.
I’m in favor. Feddit has proven before this incident to be extremely Zionistic and Islamophobic as well.
Fuck the zioNazis and fuck the spineless cowards that run feddit.com. Death to capitalism, death to America, death to Israel, free Palestine, and ALL power to ALL the people.
And frankly, I don’t think feddit.org deserve to be a part of the SDF community, or polite society in general. ZioNazis are exactly that, Nazis with a different coat of paint, and should be treated as such.
BUT I still disagree with SDF specifically defederating instance-wide from Feddit or literally any instance. IMO the only reason I would support SDF defederating an instance is if simply federating with the instance is technically dangerous for out instance.
Because we don’t deserve to be punished for feddit.org’s crimes by throwing away our ability to communicate with, agitate, or monitor Feddit’s users and mod team. I totally sympathize with other instances that specifically and openly curate what their users can and can’t see nuking their federation if that is what their users want. Totally reasonable. But I suspect that a lot of us are here precisely because we don’t defederate from anyone, even if they suck or deserve worse. A lot of us are on this instance deliberately because we want to curate our own feeds.
And personally, I reject the premise that communicating with a person means that I respect or endorse them in any capacity. For example, I’ve replied to various neoliberals all over the Fediverse because they said something horrible or uninformed that needs to be addressed, at least for the sake of everyone else watching. I don’t endorse or respect the neoliberal worldview, but unfortunately in the US and a lot of places we’ve ruined, neoliberalism is the “default” ideology, so that’s where discussions from any other position have to start from: rejecting neoliberalism and disproving its lies.
And as alluded to above, this is my position about neo-nazis, PDF files, cops, and ${insert any morally reprehensible group here} with respect to this instance as well.
So no, I don’t support us site-wide defederating from Feddit, just as I wouldn’t support site-wide defederating any instance unless federation somehow posed a technical existential threat to this instance. Not that they haven’t earned it, because they’ve earned way the fuck worse, but we don’t deserve to lose our ability to speak to them or monitor their monsters.
Well-argued. I’ll give this some thought.
As excessive as defederating an entire instance is, think about how insane banning anti-zionist speech across an entire instance is.
It’s not like its one gardening sublemmy or the diary of Anne frank guy, its an entire instance banning a specific form of antifascism. That’s unhinged and their justification is flimsy as hell.
If you wanna stay on that instance spam them with pictures of children in Gaza 24/7 until they ban you or reverse course on this decision.
It’s plainly an attempt at palestinian erasure. They decided to ban anti zionism the same week Israel announced they would be exporting 1 million Palestinians to Libya and occupying Gaza permanently. It’s not an accident, or for their safety, or German law, its genocide and feddit apparently wants to mandate it big brother style where you cant talk about eastasia.
It’s insane. Power tripping mods to a new stratosphere. Nobody should just be okay with this. Speaking for palestine without fear of being banned is one of the main reasons a lot of us left reddit in the first place. Don’t bring that shit here!
Yeah I’m sold. The more I looked into this instance the more horrified I’ve become. Straight up proud to be fascists they are.
Banning certain actions and defederation; both are censorship and also patronization. I am against any form of censorship. There are very few exceptions, mainly malicious actions, which need to be banned to protect your users.
We all have the choice to hide certain terms, communities or servers. A much better way is to get confronted by it and actively protest to this kind of censorship. Share your views, your opinions in a non-offending way. Give the others the chance to get educated. If it fails, move on and enjoy your life somewhere else.
I know, my views are quite unpopular. But they are mine. Feel free to block me at any time.
This is the third comment making me reconsider.
Removed by mod
Politely disagree
The link appears broken, so I don’t know the specifics here, but defederation really needs to be a last resort as it kinda halts any chance of the conversation going the other way too. It helps create and support the extremified echo chambers that actively cause so many of our societal problems.
If the instance is particularly problematic or exclusively causes harm, then it might be appropriate to nuke em. But it also effectively tells the entirety of Lemmy that this is not a conversation worth having, and that it is wrong (at least socially) to ever interact with these people. And, it tells the folks being defederated that whatever they are saying must be valid because it gets an extreme reaction. People are exceedingly unlikely to admit wrongdoing and change their behavior when action is taken against their community of like-minded buddies (echo chamber), they double down and become even more polarized.
I know you mentioned speaking against defederation before, and I obviously don’t fully understand the details here, but I feel like it bears repeating that defederation has to go beyond the moral opinions of any individual if we want to stave off circling the drain of overreactive garbage that places like Reddit or Twitter became.
Thank you speaking up, the double speak and lack of humanity here for Palestinians is sickening and anyone who doesn’t condemn it is complicit in helping sweep a genocide under the rug…
I only would agree with defederating if it’s proven that they are blocking anti-genocide content on other servers from being visible to their users.
In general I believe that maintaining lines of communication with those who otherwise believe in reprehensible ideologies is best, both in order to better understand such backwards ideologies, and also to provide a lifeline back to consensus reality for people who’ve been swept up by them.
I also believe that in the majority of cases, users should wield the power to instance-block for themselves. Or at least, servers where this is the case are the ones I prefer to participate on.
However, if it becomes clear that feddit.org admins are censoring content external to their instance due to their support of Zionism, then my first objection becomes irrelevant, and the second would be questionable, given the efforts of admins to put external fedi content thru a pro-genocide filter. At that point, defederation would be both warranted and wise.
As a Jew, fuck Zionism, It’s a stain on Judaism and Israel itself. Guess fuck feddit.org too.
Removed by mod
I don’t want to defederate anything. What feddit is doing sounds super Orwellian and shitty, but so is .ml sometimes, and I still do stuff which seems positive over there. The thing that lead me to SDF in the first place was the low blocked/blocked by.
Agreed. I periodically check to confirm that SDF is not blocking other instances and feel pride at the free thought. That’s part of why I changed my mind and amended the post. This is a topic that matters more to me than a lot of other reasons people on other instances have called for defedding. But rational arguments in the comments pulled me back. Thanks all.
Yeah let’s fight censorship with more censorship!! Total isolation!
If you isolate the users of feddit then you won’t help them on having different views.
I have no input but Lemmy is closer to communes than a unified social media, you shun those that don’t follow social rules like feddit has done, no?
Why help people who are comfortable with “I think brown people dying is neutral to good” is rational thinking?
If they’re tolerant of death, and comfortable of being on a Nazi Table of “Maybe murder isn’t bad”, they’re either too stupid to know better or too useful for Zionists.
You’re free to educate them. Good luck without being banned for being “anti-Zionist”
Removed by mod
some of the politics communities are starting to get there.
